A bibliophile and YA addict stuck in the awkward stage of becoming an "adult"
This book is by far the best and most amazing threequel (yes, that is a word) I have ever read. I honestly cannot find words to describe how perfect this novel is, so I will attempt to say what this novel isn't.
Let me say that I rarely consider a book to truly deserve such a high rating. I most often give this rating during the aftereffects of finishing a great book -- the "book high," if you will -- or because I ignore or overlook the tiny flaws I noticed while reading. However, it has been quite a while since I finished this book, yet I still feel that this book deserves a perfect rating. Why? Because Fangirl is the perfect blend of teen and adult content, wit and humor, sadness and emotion, and fantastic writing. I think everyone should give this book a try, or at least read the synopsis, because even if it is outside your interest type, it is a wonderful book.
As sequels go, Scarlet was an exciting and well-written continuation of the series. Rather than focusing on the main character of the first novel, Cinder, Meyer introduces us to a whole group of new characters with humorous and realistic personalities. This, along with an action and twist-filled plot, developed the series so much more and kept me engaged. I’m much more invested after reading this book!
Overall Rating: 3.5/5
I adore the idea of this book–assassin nuns working for the mythological god of Death during the 1400’s–and it was this idea that kept my attention while reading. LaFevers certainly creates an enjoyable and romantic storyline while intertwining action and politics, so this book appeals to large amount of genres and readers.
While I was fascinated by the idea of the novel (as stated before), I felt disappointed at times when reading. The book promises action and violence and weaponry (which oddly makes me excited–don’t know what that says about me), but focuses so much more on politics and romance. While Ismae’s time training as an assassin is mentioned, it seems glossed over, and I wanted to read so much more than I was given.
Because action seemed to take the backseat in the plot, the romance between Ismae and Duval was overwhelming to me. As told from Ismae’s point of view, the story focused a lot on her interactions with and feelings for Duval, which I would have expected from a romance novel, not from a book promising violence and assassins. But this disappointment may be my fault–perhaps I judged the book’s genre and content too quickly.
Although I do criticize the plot, I loved Ismae’s personality. If nothing else, read this book for the heroine. Her no-nonsense attitude and impulsive nature drew me in (as did her sarcasm and wit, which I always appreciate). While her relationship with Duval sometimes left her lovestruck, she stayed an assassin at heart throughout the entire book, which kept me reading. Additionally, I could easily see her growth as a character in the first book of the series, which I applaud LaFevers for, as often characters in teen novels grow over the course of the series, but not the individual book. Throughout the plot, Ismae became more and more independent and free-thinking, which I believe makes her not only relatable, but also well-developed.
I have to give LaFevers even more kudos for this, for she didn’t use first-person point of view, and moreover, used language and writing that fit the setting and characters! I know this may seem trivial to some, but the writing style, to me, balanced out the romance-based plot and enhanced the characters and dialogue.
Full review at http://transitionreads.wordpress.com/2014/05/05/review-every-day/
Overall, I was really impressed and entertained by this book. I definitely was hooked by the first chapter, not only by the crapton of nerdy references, but also by the characters. Art3mis, Aech, and Wade all have fantastic, realistic dialogue that was seriously funny and fun to read. Although I love the content--the 80's references, the video game setting, the futuristic world--it was these characters that made the book for me. I definitely recommend this to anyone who likes to read sci-fi, fantasy, or futuristic novels.
This book proves that John Green is one of the wittiest, funniest, and most original authors I have ever read. All the characters are so weirdly unique and yet so believable at the same time. I have no problem stating that John Green is my favorite author of teen fiction after reading this book.
1
Everything--EVERYTHING--in this book is gold. I finished it a month ago, and I'm still having feels; it's that good. And to be honest, it is by far the best sequel I have ever read, which is not something I take lightly. Everything in this book is as fresh and new as it was in the first, and I couldn't put it down. Literally. I read it in six hours.
I had a really hard time deciding whether or not to give this book five stars--I enjoyed reading it that much! But in the end, there were a few details that made me choose four stars over five.
DUDES. THIS BOOK IS AWESOME.
AMAZING. SO WORTH IT. EVERYONE MUST READ THIS.
I literally don't know how to rate this book. On one hand, I am awed by Flynn's ability to create such an emotional roller coaster of a book, as well as the frustratingly complex and scarily real characters Flynn presents. But on the other hand, I absolutely despise said frustratingly complex and scarily real characters. I sympathized and cared for both characters for the first half of the book, then hated (and occasionally sympathized with) each for the latter half.
Should you read this book?
1